The Best Pizza in Roanoke, VA
Pizza in Roanoke isn’t one-size-fits-all. Some nights you want a giant, foldable New York–style slice, other nights you’re craving a blistered Neapolitan pie with a glass of wine, and sometimes you just need the biggest pizza in town to split with friends. Roanoke has all of that (and then some).
What makes Roanoke’s pizza scene special is its mix of authentic tradition, neighborhood charm, and a few creative twists that keep things interesting. From family-run staples that locals swear by to downtown spots shaking things up with monthly specials, there’s a slice for every craving.
To help you navigate it all, we’ve rounded up the best pizza spots in town in two ways:
- By style (because sometimes you know exactly what kind of pie you’re in the mood for)
- By neighborhood (so you know where to go, wherever you find yourself in the city)
So grab a napkin, bring your appetite, and let’s talk pizza in the Star City!
Pizza by Style in Roanoke
For the Giant Slice Experience
You can’t talk Roanoke pizza without mentioning Benny’s. Their giant New York–style slices are legendary, bigger than your head and foldable in true NYC fashion. The menu is intentionally simple: cheese, pepperoni, and a rotating daily topping. Sometimes less really is more. This is the go-to for a quick downtown lunch or late-night snack after a concert.
For Creative, Trendy Pies
Bobby’s brings the fun to Roanoke’s pizza scene with a menu that’s always changing. Expect playful flavor combos, rotating specials, and plenty of cheesy goodness to keep things interesting. It’s the kind of spot where you can count on finding something a little different every time you go. And since it shares space with Bubblecake, you can always finish off your night with a cupcake (because who says pizza and dessert can’t go together?).
For Classic New York Style
Family-owned and serving locals for decades, New York Pizza is a bit of a local secret. They offer both thin Neapolitan pies and hearty Sicilian-style squares, along with specialties like the ricotta-topped White pie, the fully loaded Neapolitan Special, and a veggie-packed favorite. Whether you grab a whole pie or just a hot, fresh slice, it’s the kind of spot that keeps regulars coming back week after week!
At Tony Avellino, it’s all about the crust, crispy, foldable, and just the right balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Fans swear it’s the best New York pizza in town, with both Neapolitan and Sicilian pies that deliver every time. From a classic cheese slice to old-world no-cheese options, everything here feels true to big-city pizza roots. Quick service, generous toppings, and consistent quality make Tony Avellino the kind of place you’ll order from again (and again)!
Frank’s is the kind of spot that feels like a tradition! Their pies come out hot, hearty, and loaded with toppings, making it a go-to for family dinners or Friday night takeout. The menu leans classic, think pepperoni, sausage, and supreme-style combinations, with that comforting, no-frills vibe that keeps regulars loyal. Big portions, familiar flavors, and a crust that can hold its own make Frank’s a longtime local favorite!
For Thin-Crust & Artisan Lovers
A Grandin Village staple for over 20 years, Grace’s Place is known for its scratch-made dough, fresh ingredients, and thin-crust pizzas that keep locals coming back. They also offer gluten-free options, making it easy for everyone to enjoy. With its welcoming local vibe and focus on consistency, it’s the kind of spot that feels like home every time you visit!
Fortunato is all about authenticity. It’s on our list of the best spots in Roanoke for a reason! This downtown spot brings Neapolitan soul with Appalachian heart, serving wood-fired pies that taste straight out of Italy but feel right at home in Roanoke. The crust is blistered just right, the toppings are simple and high-quality, and everything pairs perfectly with a glass of wine or one of their craft cocktails. It’s pizza done the traditional way, slow, intentional, and always worth savoring.
Jaybird Tavern is where pizza meets hangout! Their thin, crispy pies are perfect for sharing over a round of drinks, especially on the pet-friendly patio. But what really keeps people talking is their monthly special, a wild, over-the-top creation that delivers on shock factor and makes you want to come back just to see what they’ll do next. It’s fun, unfussy, and exactly the kind of spot you want in your pizza rotation!
For Big Groups & Family-Friendly Nights
Highlander doesn’t do small. Their pizzas are massive, piled high with toppings, and perfect for sharing with a group (or tackling solo if you’re brave). It’s the kind of late-night spot where the menu is big, the slices are bigger, and you never leave hungry!
Basil Pizza is one of those hidden gems that makes you feel like family the second you walk in. Their dough is packed with flavor, the toppings are fresh, and the calzones and baklava are just as much of a draw as the pizza itself. It’s authentic, welcoming, and the kind of spot that quickly turns into a new favorite once you’ve tried it!
Pizza by Neighborhood
Downtown Roanoke
- Benny Marconi’s (giant New York–style slices)
- Fortunato (wood-fired, authentic Neapolitan-style)
- Jaybird Tavern (crispy pies + shock-factor monthly specials)
Grandin / West End
- Grace’s Place (local staple with neighborhood vibe, gluten-free options)
- Bobby’s Hot & Cheesy (creative pies + Bubblecake cupcakes)
South Roanoke / Brambleton
- Frank’s on Brambleton (hearty, classic pies)
Vinton / East Side
- New York Pizza (local secret with Sicilian & Neapolitan pies)
Southwest / Electric Rd Area
- Tony Avellino (New York–style, reliable classics)
- Highlander Pizza (massive pies, toppings galore)
Williamson Rd Area
- Basil Pizza (authentic, family-run hidden gem)
Looking for more Roanoke restaurant recommendations? Check out our full guide to the best Roanoke restaurants!
